Dobby and harry reddit. Using the mirror he could see Harry was in danger.

Dobby and harry reddit It is so hard. He had meth head / crackpot level strength. Edit: Added a break point for the points to make it easier to read. I think Kreature deserves more love and admiration as he originally cared not for Harry but ended up not only helping the golden trio but looking after them for months and finding people like Mundungus at At this level, Dobby is Harry. In Deathly Hallows Part 1, Dobby reappears and proclaims himself a free elf, yet, he still wore rags. Why? I think cause Lucius threw the sock in Dobby's direction (Dobby was able to catch it) it can be construed by the magic as a gift. Harry blushed and Dumbledore simply looked amused as Dobby bounced around the room, "Dobby is so happy, Dobby is free and he has his own wizard and he's going to be the best master ever" The headmaster coughed politely, causing the room to quiet, "Well, as joyous an occasion as this is, I do have one more matter of importance to bring up. Also even if Gollum had the ring, Dobby's magic Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. In a Reddit thread that asks followers, "What is your unpopular Harry Potter opinion?" one fan has confessed that they do not like Dobby. My thoughts, for what it's worth. Dobby was not there. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Harry discovers that the creature on his bed is a house-elf named Dobby. House-elves have a lot of magic, and from what we saw of Dobby, he was good at using it. Rowling has a tendency to make annoying characters - Dobby and Colin specifically come to mind - noisy, pesky characters. To bring dobby along as a house elf to do their bidding is so vastly different than Aberforth seeing they were in danger and sending Dobby to help them one time. I find a lot of similarities between Dobby and Gollum. What he lacks the n strength he makes up with magic. Their lives were also turned upside down due to Harry when Voldemort was ‘defeated’. Dobby even expands upon this and helps Winky. It still hurts me. Giving him a wand and DADA training in R3 will probably just amplify his powers (and it’s no wonder why, considering their fear of non-humans, the Ministry of Magic outlawed non-humans from wielding wands). They simply removed him from 4,5,6 which really cheapens his death to' Dobby also warned Harry multiple times that something really bad was about to happen, and it was also clear that he can't go into details because of his allegiance to his masters. Humans probably never took into consideration that an elf could be free or even WANT to be free. It's like so annoying, and the real reason i could see why they cut him out of the following films we'll discuss, is because they really didn't know any better, or better yet didn't know he would become such a huge and important character later down the line. The same could be said for Bellatrix and Voldermort. Dobby gives harry a pair of socks. Not to mention he does quite a lot of good things of his own free will which help harry and never asks for anything in return (he gave aharry gillyweed. An elf freed by the owner was a disgrace and an outcast so to speak. The defeat of the Dark Lord also led to an upturn in the general welfare of House Elves, so Dobby admires him. It is the absolute worst death because it was so innocent. He appears in books 2, 4,5,6, and 7, so Harry has much more of a relationship with him and the death hits him and the reader way harder. “Bad Dobby Bad Dobby” Harry lunged for the elf wrapping his arms around its torso and wrestling it away from the drawers. They both gave their life fighting for them as well, and even though Bellatrix is doing terrible things to our other favorite characters there’s something captivating about her passion for chaos and evil that makes her much more interesting than any of the other antagonists to me. Without magic movie Dobby doesn’t stand a chance. Chapter 1 Discussion. Here, Dobby blushed a bit, "Dobby shouldn't repeat it, it was very naughty. " In the book, Harry hands Lucius Malloy Tom Riddle’s destroyed diary. Not a house elf, though. Harry actually did tell Dobby not to die: "Dobby, no, don't die, don't die" I think elf magic, though powerful, is limited. I also think that both Narcissa and Bellatrix are savvy enough to know that while Dobby was a lost cause loyalty wise, Kreature had Pure Blood sympathies and would cooperate with the right interactions. He’s definitely one of my favourite characters outside of Harry,Ron and Hermione. 10 votes, 15 comments. [1:6] And Dobby saw Mr. Recall that when Dobby (who wasn't even enslaved anymore!) wanted to warn Harry about Umbridge's raid, he was compelled to beat himself. Harry did not put too much thought even into freeing Dobby, but it still doesnt lessen the impact this action had on Dobby's life. Hurt slightly more than Sirius' death. So closing the barrier would have been completely useless, without further action on Dobby's part. When we see them through Harry's eyes we get a sense of his impatience. Take for example the difference between Dobby and Winky. Dobby is subsequently buried without the use of magic by Harry. I don’t like any of the house elves, to be honest. His intentions may have been good in the grand scheme of things, but honestly Dobby had fuck all empathy or regard for the shit Harry was going through at home or that how much Hogwarts and his friends meant to him. So much for caring about him! In book 6 Dobby helps Harry with his investigation into Draco Malfoy. The hand jerk that Harry feels is not Dobby trying to take charge, like Harry thinks, but Dobby jerking in pain because the knife had fully plunged into his chest. In movie canon Harry hasn't seen Dobby in about 5 years (8 years real life time). Hedwig was brutally killed after protecting Harry from a deatheater, tanked a killing curse that was destined to Harry and fell Dobby's death just fucking hurts. Even if he did know healing spells, he wasn't thinking straight at the moment. Dobby views Harry as the person who brought down the dark lord. Plus Harry would eventually have graduated and needed his help. —— Join our discord server: https://discord. Why is this or was Dobby wearing better clothes in the books and this was only in the movies Harry still didn’t know what Dobby was talking about and as he opened his mouth to ask. Dobby would, and did, do anything he could for Harry. In deathly hallows, the scene where they were all escaping from Malfoy manor with Dobby’s help, and bellatrix throws a knife as they were disapparating, as they get to the cottage where Bill and Fleur were staying in, Harry discovers dobby was stabbed (I’ve always wondered why the knife didn’t get to the goblin instead, anyways) He’s frantically trying to save the little elf and looks One of my favorite lines in the whole series comes while Harry is digging Dobby's grave: "And understanding blossomed in the darkness" Up until that point Harry had become obsessed with finding the Hallows and almost forgot about the Horcruxes. He's a bit of comic relief in the book but also his devotion to Harry helps Harry in the tasks. Hurt way worse than Dumbledore's death. All of the things about Dobby being heroic, innocent, about sacrificing himself, all true. He loved Harry and gave his life to save him, so An unpopular perspective is put forth by a user whose account has since been deleted. DOBBY2 Dobby, her friend and fellow free elf Dobby and Winky had met sometime prior to the 1994 Quidditch World Cup, and were apparently on good enough terms for Winky to be informed on his current whereabouts. I remember so clearly Dobby saying to Harry in one of the earlier movies "Dobby never meant to kill Harry Potter, only maim, or seriously injure". Share Related Harry Potter Harry Potter (book series) Young adult literature Reading, Writing, and Literature forward back. And Dobby said that since Harry more or less defeated Voldemort, things got better for house elves. Dobby was so injured that he couldn't have possibly taken any action to save himself. Harry gave Dobby the sock that freed him, in a roundabout way. Chapter 3 Discussion. 2022, 14:54 Uhr. Never mind wizards vs muggles; Harry has his own thing going on. Warned him of Umbridge finding the DA. Dobby does display some powerful magic and harry even asks him how he's able to do it and he always replies "dobby is a house elf. They were sent Dobby, they didn't choose to include him. Lifting cakes onto people, etc. " Winky: "But I knows Dobby too, sir!" — Harry Potter and Winky discuss their mutual acquaintance. Round 2: Dobby 10/10. It's the same reason dobby can apparate into the Durselys house in COS while every witch and wizard has to wait at the front door for Harry in books afterwards or get some other way. This was a new thing that Mr. “Master has given a sock. The only other ability is his invisibility and they can both do that. He is at Hogwarts when Winky is there, though. New comments cannot be posted. He stretched out a hand and pulled the sharp blade from the elf's body, then dragged off his own jacket and covered Dobby in it like a blanket'' His last action towards Dobby is giving him a piece of his own clothes. Something the average magic user would probably be able to do. So apparently you can see Dobby and Winky riding llamas in Goblet of Fire. Reddit's largest humor depository Members Online. Dobby was closer, but Harry had closure on his death. " They are definitely capable of some extreme magic but I think you're correct in your assessment that they are so stuck in their slavery that they just can't bring themselves to use it. u/Ok-Cut-1570 has a total of 9 galleons, 0 sickles Dobby told Harry about the Room of Requirement in OotP and later warned the DA that Aberforth had gotten the other half of the mirror that Sirius gave Harry in OotP. No wizard had called an elf friend before. The amount of trouble he stirred up for Harry in the Chamber of Secrets, WHAT THE FUCK. They knew it was a sacrifice for Dobby to help them and one Harry felt immense guilt for after the fact. Also a pistol actually being able to hurt Voldemort or any wizard Dobby's death just fucking hurts. And they both have similar physical fetures like big eyes, small and crinkle skin. Reddit's Home for the Dresden Files book series by Jim Butcher. I Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. I've been waiting for that scene to come up, but then Harry freed Dobby, and Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Master gave it to Dobby. Dobby stomps all rounds. "Dobby, no. Chapter Summary: . Not to mention nobody bats an eye when the supposedly “well treated” Hogwarts house elves are forced to 460 votes, 67 comments. "Harry looked back down at Dobby. Not Dobby). But, book 7 when both of these characters die in loyal service to Harry and his goals, it comes as a double punch in the gut for the reader. A sub-reddit for the fans and critics of the show It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia. This is an unofficial fan subreddit - JK TERFling owns everything. I think Dobby knew that, and he had to make Harry want to leave without revealing it was truly him. It's revealed at some point that House Elf magic doesn't follow wizarding rules. The user states that the obnoxious house-elf, Kreacher, who served the Black family at Grimmauld Place, was at least "a good and productive character" within the narrative while Dobby only seems to annoy. For Harry Potter’s own good. Also Kreacher became Harry's elf and had him go work at Hogwarts when he didn't need him. Harry has a connection to Dobby that stretches books. “Master gave it to Dobby. Dobby's loyalty to Harry all for a simple act of kindness is meant to be noted because it was life changing for Dobby. a question the small elf let out a shriek. Cedric, Ted, Tonks, Moody weren't super close to Harry. Dobby knows this and rightly looks up to Harry as his saviour. I can’t put a finger on why though. When Harry found out Dobby was the Malfoy's house elf, it became a View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. “What did you say?” “Got a sock,” said Dobby in disbelief. Although Dobby helped rescue Harry and the others from Malfoy Manor, any house elf would have done it as they saw Harry as a saviour as he defeated the dark lord. Dobby tells Harry quite soon into their talk that he had to hurt himself in order to warn Harry at all; if I guess that Dobby knew the diary was Voldemort's and therefore went to Harry since he's the biggest target. Harry freed Dobby from a lifetime of abuse, neglect and overwork. The only other potential you mention is Fred. "** I love Dobby! Dobby threw his arms around Harry’s middle and hugged him. It was his sock, but was "handed to him" by Lucius. “Master has given a sock,” said the elf in wonderment. Dobby's death . But Dobby told Professor Flitwick that Umbridge always secretly wanted to be a house-elf, and just didn't like being disturbed, and she put me in charge of doing Hogwarts things. I interpreted at the time, bear in mind I was only about 10, I thought they were like pets but could speak English. The relationship between Harry and Dobby was known, and Dobby worked at Hogwarts. In the Chamber of Secrets when Dobby dropped the cake on Mrs Mason’s head, why didn’t Harry just lie to Dobby and say “I won’t To be fair, Dobby seemed like a pyscho, I see Harry not wanting to play games with an unhinged house-elf, and decided the best course of action is to be straight about his intentions. I actually appreciate the movies for not having too much Dobby just like in the books. But also he should be wearing sweaters and hats You have given u/Ok-Cut-1570 a Reddit Galleon. The clothes thing is just a custom. "The left sock was bright red, and had a pattern of broomsticks upon it; the right sock was green, with a pattern of snitches. Reply [deleted] Artist did a good job portraying terrified Dobby, it pulls View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. It began banging its head on the chest of drawers next to Harry’s bed. “Master threw it, and Dobby caught it, and Dobby — Dobby is free. Where he answered to Snape. Had Lucius thrown the sock at Harry or in a garbage can, it wouldn't have counted. He just didn't know the appropriate ways to help Harry because he was never shown kindness by anyone The first time we see Dobby, he basically hurts himself, then gets Harry in trouble. Lucius Malfoy and Dobby by Vladislav Pantic: This thread the first time Harry ended up there. Harry believes in some way that he is responsible for Dobby. So even though he had never met Harry before, Harry probably meant more to Dobby than a random muggleborn. Old Because to our knowledge you can't separate across continents although Dobby could go to Ireland, but no the thing says Harry getting one in London and that wouldn't work. Well, I mean, Dobby was hit by a knife in the chest (iirc). I think that if either Narcissa or Draco had shown him kindness he wouldn't have tried to help Harry. Dobby calls Malfoy a bad person and then immediately tries to throw his face in the Gryffindor common room fireplace. Everyone thinks that Harry would have been in Hogwarts the next day. The same goes for Dobby. Harry mentions exactly when Lucius had slipped Ginny the Diary. But I hate dobby the most. My question: How did Dobby know that Kreacher was apparating to Harry, and how the hell did he start fighting him mid-apparation? Wow I never thought of it like this, I actually completely agree. This subreddit is for all things Drarry, the romantic pairing of Harry Potter and Draco Malfoy. It's not like Dobby planned to eventually get freed when he betrayed the Malfoys and went to give Harry a warning - Dobby's initial idea was to keep Harry out of Hogwarts, after all. Help my nephew get 1000 signatures on this petition to let him move into his laundry room Harry, Fleur, Hermione, Ron and Dobby are Fred, Daphne, Velma, Shaggy and the Scoobs. His heart pure, his spirit free, In death, he is finally set free. Yeah I think the Hedwig looks great and that's probably the way they should go with the line. But looking at Dobby for example, his magic use is typically more mischievous and basic. Dobby hated the Malfoys and went out of his way to try to save Harry. If Dobby was doing it all, Harry wouldn’t have needed to spin on the spot and think of their destination - but he does, because he’s the one apparating them. So this must mean he noticed but didn't think much of it. The last two days I’ve been rewatching all the movies on blu ray and today I’m watching Deathly Hallows pts 1&2 back to back and I just finished Part One,Dobby’s death is just so heartbreaking and definitely made me tear up and always does. Dobby "served" Harry but was treated like a friend and in turn protected Harry. Could make it like the newer scaled down Star Wars ships around the €/$50 range (TIE Fighter, X Wing, Slave I). gg/aEMFNpXT3Z. Please recommend something anything that does this. (Dobby's next attempt is almost murder) Dobby can apparate two people at the same time out of Malfoy Manor. All important. In the book Dobby was critically injured- the knife in relation to his tiny body made a large wound. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Discussion of the show, pictures from the show and anything else. He was only in two/three books. It doesn't have to be sacrifice or courage necessarily, just moments between Harry and a house-elf that feel meaningful. He was a house-elf who served Dobby is considered a hero or a jerk, but his relationship with Harry was quite strange. I think that come from Elves being servants and being forced to obey the humans. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. While Fred also died during the battle for Hogwarts, he isn't the parental type to lead another into making such a sacrifice. Von: Michelle Anskeit. I just want humanized house elves. He talks about how poorly house elves were treated under lord Voldemort and doesn’t want anything bad to happen to Harry Potter. He's in the second movie, where he is admittedly kind of annoying. But Slytherin's monster attacks muggle-borns, and Harry is not a muggle-born, so there's no reason for Dobby to think Harry will be a target. Elves Dobby and Winky Can Be Seen Briefly in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, They Were Cut Out Due to Time Constraints. "Dobby must do it, sir," Dobby said gravely, staring at Harry with unblinking eyes as he clawed and scrambled to get away. Kreacher somehow ended up in Hogwarts and Snape was on their side, but they didn’t know that, and they were too scared to try. ” Lucius Malfoy stood frozen, staring at the elf then he lunged at Harry. More to the point, however, is that Dobby serves as a loyal and steadfast ally and helper to Harry throughout the series despite having no obligation to do so. Feel free to discuss the books, television series, comic books, RPG, I’ve never liked Dobby. The one exception was the other reddit post, where a couple other people said they remember it from Dobby talking to Harry in the infirmary in Chamber of Secrets. It already tells you that Harry does not see Kreacher as a slave, whose service can just be taken as a given; in fact the entire Kreacher arc (and also Dobby) illustrates quite well that ultimately, House Elves should be seen as voluntary servants, even friends, and that they will defend themselves against oppression. " I always did wonder about that! The character Lucius would never ever dare to try and kill Harry at Hogwarts (though the film was created before GoF came out and all Jason Isaacs really knew was that Lucius was definitely not a friend of For sure, Dobby never intended Harry to steal a car and then get lost in the forest in need of a car, but JKR did intend that, Reddit's Home for the Dresden Files book series by Jim Butcher. He didn’t necessarily expect Harry to be a better person when he first decided to help him. Taking Harry to a desert island only takes 5 seconds. Slowly Dobby grew on me. When Harry heard the signature crack of apparition, he saw two elves fighting. Related Sir" or something when Harry incorrectly calls Now when an author has Dobby steal communication devices from Harry's friends, orchestrates Harry getting bit by an ultravenomous snake that leaves him bedridden for weeks and sabotages an ambush operation led by Harry (who is trained in swordplay and magic) and 20 elite soldiers by locking him in a room when he's about to back them up it kinda hits the limit of what's acceptable. Members Online. Sure in hindsight it really wasn’t. And then he shows up again in the seventh movie, only to die while heroically rescuing the Trio . While rereading the books and getting to Dobby's death makes me feel sad,In the movies I simply can't get sad because he only appears in 2 and 7(and all he does in 7 is save Harry and then die). Harry is responsible for Dobby's death, not because he asked Dobby to never save him again, but because he said Voldemort's name! Ron had come back by that point and let them know the name was cursed, he absolutely knew it would have consequences, but he was just so As Dobby and Harry are not even the same type of being, and probably inter species relationships are not terribly common, I’m sticking with Ginny. I understand dobby had major importance to the plot of Harry Potter all the way to his death but he's obnoxious and I can't stand them. (I think Mundungus had sold it to him after stealing it from Grimmauld Place). Also Dobby would win. Dobby returns to save Harry from the Malfoy manor, and Dobby helps Harry gain the ownership of the Elder Wand from Draco without any use of magic. He is intensely loyal to Harry: When we first meet him, Dobby is putting himself in danger by visiting Harry to warn him of eminent danger. Round 1: Gollum 10/10. He would win because Gollums main weapon is subterfuge and Dobby is highly attuned to the good and bad within people - he recognizes it and would not easily fall for tricksies. Though treated poorly in his life, His bravery shone through, And in the end, he gave his all, For Harry, Ron, and Hermione too. By contrast, he is in every book except 1 and 3, and is a very important source of information about the Wizarding World, Hogwarts Castle, and helps move the plot along in Generally Harry lies to protect people or because the person messing with him is a dick; he’ll lie to Filch and Snape cuz screw them they suck and are unfair. She has a drinking problem and he is one of the only House Elves willing to be near her, as to the othe relves they are out casts for being freed. " Harry raised an eyebrow, "Flitwick didn't believe that, did he?" To this point, when Harry has Kreacher and Dobby follow Malfoy in HBP, Kreacher comments about how much better it would be to serve Malfoy than Harry. It goes by quickly, but I Harry Potter 1 and 2 vs Harry Potter 3,4,5,6,7 and 8. Malloy opens it, notices the wet sock from Harry, and promptly tosses it without a care in world. Year 2 Year 7 I feel like Year 2 Dobby looks more accurate than year 7. Showed him how to find the room of requirement. In GoF, Dobby comes to work at Hogwarts, but Harry never actually visits 17 Meinungen zu „Harry Potter“, mit denen Fans sich so unbeliebt machen wie Filch. I It may not be specifically about Harry but Dobby knows that the plan has something to do with Voldemort and the Chamber. Dobby is just the purest fictional character to ever exist. He was only annoying at the start of CoS for me. And since Harry is our window into that world, it’s a crushing loss to us. Mere seconds past from the moment Harry noticed Dobby was injured until he passed away. I imagine even if they managed to fix the wound with magic (none of Harry, Ron and Hermione are Healers, so they'd have to waste time getting a Healer), it'd probably already be too late because Dobby lost a lot of blood and they aren't likely to have Blood-Replenishing Potions on them. 1. So upon reaching Harrys room, it was the first time he was on a bed and did not think he as a house elf was allowed to sit or lay down on a bed. Feel free to discuss the books, television series, comic books, Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. So now I'm going absolutely insane, and I've been trying to speak to other people to see what they remember. I can't seem to watch or read Sirius' death anymore. Or check it out in the app stores DoBbY Locked post. Harry Potter, Sir had done. He risked everything to do the right thing. “Socks are Dobby’s favorite, favorite clothes, For discussion of Harry Potter fanfiction. Harry was always true to them he arguably never disrepair the boys he even gave dobby the sock to prank Malfoy Hermione went to hard but harry was always there saving the world and being a kind person. If it wasn’t a combination of these two factors, and say Ron had tried the same thing, I don’t think Dobby would have It's devoid of emotion. He does pretty much the same thing all year until saved by Harry, another damsel in distress for the great boy My opinion of Dobby follows Harry's feelings about him. I have been a long time Harry Potter fan and I just started getting into the hobbit. “Dobby must do it, for Harry Potter’s own good” Vernon Dursley is already every type of abusive but physical. He might have been annoying at times, but he was also powerful and smart and loyal. Dobby wanted to be free but Winky fell apart. Dobby sees Harry as a hero, an icon, everything the 12-year-old craves. So I am wondering if there's anything to these connections. While Dobby's death was tragic in both forms of media, I have a big gripe with the movies. If she hadn’t, as OP says, almost resurrected Voldemort, Harry wouldn’t have accomplished much of anything in that situation. Dobby is funny: While some might disagree, I always laugh when Dobby appears. Dobby is trying to stop Harry getting caught up in Lucius’s to mess Arthur up with his plot with the diary, the basilisk and Ginny; Lucius actually doesn’t care very much at that stage whether Harry is or isn’t at Hogwarts; it’s only Dobby that seems concerned about that, which is why Dobby takes it upon himself to warn Harry even knowing he’ll have to punish himself extensively for In CoS, Dobby was owned by and worked for the Malfroys, a dark wizard family, who despised Dumbledore due to his muggle loving ways. So he got in touch with Dobby - who was still working at Hogwarts - and told him to go and rescue everyone. ” “What’s that?” spat Mr. . Any recs appreciated! Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. He didn’t do it because he thought it would win him friends or freedom. View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. For one they both speak in the third person. I'm trying to hold my tears for this one. Harry Potter, Sir freed Dobby from his bad master and called Dobby his friend. Dobby decides to kidnap Harry instead of blocking the barrier and all the professors go crazy looking for him . Dobby, is practically everyone's favorite character, yet he really gets the short end of the stick in the films. [1:7] So Mr. He is good, he is kind, and he helps Harry stay anchored to his own humanity when all the horrible stuff happens. Kommentare Drucken Teilen He was an ugly creature that freaked me out as a kid and moreover had an annoying voice. Stand: 29. Dobby was potentially putting Harry in physical danger. Harry could be a better friend to Dobby, learn about Regulus more though Kreacher, or any number of things. Hmm yeah I've read something about Dobby on reddit saying he was truly a free elf since when Harry asked him not to die, a normal house elf would take that as an order and would seriously harm themselves if they can't follow what their master said but during Dobby's last moments, he didn't struggle or even try to harm himself for not being able to listen to what Harry told him Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. True, but Dobby did also steal Harry's letters, get him in trouble with the Durley's (who were abusive), block him from the train station, sent a bludger after him that led to his arm being broken, and whilst Dobby's reasoning may have been to protect Harry, you can understand why Harry might not feel the best towards him and be careful what he shares with Dobby. Just like Kreacher sleeping a nest of moldy items, Dobby never knew what a bed actually was. He was also disillusioned with his mentor Dumbledore. The house elves on the other hand, they were raised to be slaves but I agree with OP, over time they found themselves. Malfoy. Dobby is a peculiar and emotional being; he bursts into tears when Harry offers him a seat and punishes himself when he speaks ill of the wizards he has encountered. Seriously, I saw another user make this very same post, but I think they missed a mark. It was Lockhearts stupidity that caused the whole boneless thing. In goblet of fire, on Christmas morning, dobby wakes Harry, and the rest of the dorm up and they start exchanging presents. Here lies Dobby the elf, A loyal friend until the end. Harry, the last master of the Elder Wand, proceeds to later on "free" the Elder Wand of service as well - "buries" it to Dumbledore's tomb. Does it I think Dobby's death was so vivid and moving because we experience the story through Harry's point of view, and Dobby's death was probably the Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Throw Away Sock: Counts. Dobby had heard Harry defeated the Dark Lord, aka the Malfoys' master, and thought he must be a great wizard. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Dobby was done dirty by the movies. 03. Dobby loves Harry unconditionally. Harry, worried and stressed, didn't think straight and just called for help. Harry Potter, Sir to be a great and powerful wizard, who stood against the bad masters in defense of elves and wizards alike. Using the mirror he could see Harry was in danger. Kreacher, AND Dobby. He was one of the few house elves who had gotten out from under the thumb of oppressive wizarding norms and decided that slavery was After re-reading the books, it strikes me that Harry is actually not very nice to Dobby, except of course his funeral. I think Aberforth knew Dobby was strong and powerful. I’ve seen the movies, but haven’t gotten around to reading the books yet. As Dobby was replaced by Neville in the films (giving gillyweed, finding room of requirememt). "Dobby must do it. Dobby would have been vibrating in the corner with a smile on his face just to be his elf. Presumably, the Elves would use their special brand of magic for that, and over the years they'd probably develop new spells (or whatever they use) to do it. Dobby probably learned that when he was young (however long ago), and simply modified it a bit to grab Harry's mail as it was delivered and redirect it to himself. Then throughout the series, we see him leaping (pretty much literally) at the chance to help Harry in any way possible. It's a shame that Harry didn't summon the Dittany from Hermione's beaded bag, though. When Dobby dies, it is a crushing loss to Harry. Then up pops Dobby, who has green eyes, raggy clothes and feels abused by his ghastly [blond] family. And yet, he got his freedom and he celebrated it, made it part of his identity. Please" Harry begged, panicking as he scratched at the hand, pulling away, trying desperately, desperately to run, run far away. 9M subscribers in the harrypotter community. Of course, the controversi This is a pretty random and small detail, but I thought of something while rereading GOF. Dobby's death affected Harry profoundly. Another aspect as much as Harry wanted to preserve himself in the situation, I really think part of him didn't want to lie to Dobby who was obviously very sensitive and slightly disturbed In Chamber of Secrets, Harry asks Dobby why he wore rags and he answers that it's because it's the symbol of the house elves' oppression and slavery. That could have been dangerous. Let me just start off by saying, my Harry Potter knowledge is not the best. Master threw it, and Dobby caught it, and Dobby – Dobby is free**. After the Dursleys abandon six year old Harry in a park in Kent, Harry comes to the realization that he is an elf. Dobby, lunges in the air, and intercepts the sock, which frees him. Please read all the sub rules before posting/commenting before posting. "Dobby is a free house-elf and he can obey anyone he likes" I Dobby keeps trying to keep Harry from going to Hogwarts because he knows about Lucius Malfoy's plan to plant the diary on one of the Weasley kids and have the monster released. His vagueness and annoying voice drive me nuts and I'm glad he died. Why did Dobby speak so highly of Dumbldore to Harry on their first meeting and why did he think so highly of Harry? There's another post about this, but it's archived. Just thought that it was kind of a Then if Dumbledore would have caught Dobby, he would have been able to find out the "plot to kill Harry", which would have revealed Lucius Malfoys intent on opening the Chamber, which would also mean that Dobby betrayed his master. Character study, pre-Hogwarts, NOT a creature!fic, slightly cracky. In the movie, however, Malfoy is handed the book, and not really even looking at it, hands it to Dobby to hold. The wizard boy in his raggy clothes feels abused and over-worked; nobody on Privet Drive recognises his magical awesomeness. Took him 3 books to realize when he almost killed his brother (saved from dementors) but dudley although an ass loved Harry deep down. Dobby is Dobby sends Harry to another world so that he can be safe! I took it as Dobby was so mistreated he did not know that jumping on a bed was rude. A forest elf. " In prisoner of Azkaban he doesn't oappear, in the Goblet of fire movie Dobby wouldn't do much but be the elf who introduces winky to Harry at hogwarts, you could have him give Harry gillyweed but it takes away from Neville's movie character, same applies to Dobbys role of introducing Harry to the room of requirement in the order of the phoenix. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything We never do find out — he behaved much like a child, but then, don't all elves? In fact, elves could be very short-lived or very long-lived and we wouldn't know; some have speculated that Kreacher may have been 200 or older, and others that Dobby, despite his youthful demeanor, could just as well have been something like 50 or 60. Dobby tries to hurt Harry, endangering his life on the quidditch pitch, preventing him getting to platform 9 3/4, stealing Harry's letters, getting Harry punished at his abusive home, all to take agency away from Harry because dobby has decided he Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. In HBP after Harry's skull was cracked by McLaggen's bludger, he calls Kreacher to ask him to tail Malfoy. I just thought you were someone I know. hcffu syiuob iuqpzsb sohxil ihmp vesyha hnch rzypw kaz skdo