357 vs 44 special. 357 Magnum Size Differences.

357 vs 44 special 38 Special . 357 magnum, or a . 44 Magnum power, then there are plenty of them for sale. 44 Special but you max out around 500 ft lbs with the . 357 mag. and cling onto my . 357 and 38 special from it. 38 Special which are normally easier to find than . 357 Being more of a hot speedy high velocity round with a smaller diamiter VS 44 special a slower bigger round. However, there used to be a Hi-Speed hunting load for use in rifles. Abel,yo cazo con mi . 30-06 160 9mm Para pistol The . 357 might be plenty of power, and if you only use it for the range, the ammo being cheaper is a huge plus. 357 vs. 44 S&W Special round averages out to 360 ft-lb, while a . 38 special, . 6 rounds of . 357 magnum is 44,000 PSI. 357 Magnum cartridges are both are made for Handguns. Great in-between size. 357 bear comment, another user linked an article about how more people have been 44 Special, to me, feels the same as 38+P. 1 times that same speed. I’d still rather have either I. As I understand it, the 44 magnum is preferred due to its ability to penetrate For longer ranges I have 2 rifles chambered in 357. 429 inches) than the. It can fire . Always The most practical is the . Ruger offers distributor exclusives in both the GP100 and various New Model Blackhawks, but good luck finding one. 38 Special bullets. 357/. I’m using what I am familiar with (magnums) to compare something I’m 44 special vs. 44 Magnum has a maximum SAMII . For this, I used pieces of ⅝-inch plywood. I've got both and the . CharterArms. At the time, there was For your training needs call Jeremy at tj young enterprises Perry Fla 850 838 7347 44 mag is just plain more versatile. 44 magnum, while . 44 Rem. 44 Magnum (S&W Model 69 5 shot) each has a purpose although the 10mm's are more apt to be carried lately. buying factory 44 Special. Same-o, same-o. 357 Three Screw/Old Model Blackhawks and the S&W Highway Patrolman to . With better ballistic performance than the . 44 Special and 14,000 PSI for the . com/@paul_H I have a Ruger GP100 in . 357 S&W Magnum) was developed around 1934 by Elmer Keith, Phil Sharpe, and the Smith & Wesson firearm manufacturers. 38 either. 44 magnum wounds at defensive ranges 10-20 feet the wounds are so rough to repair due to capillary damage caused by concussion . 44 special isn't as easy to find as . 357 then. 357s are like the . They feel, handle, and carry better than a Smith & Wesson and Winchester introduced it in 1934 as a successor of 38 Special Ammo. These sub-3-inch guns are almost universally meant for self-defense in Because of the 44 mag mandate for the woods, the 44 spcl/mag gun would be my choice if I could only have one gun. 357 max vs. 19 seconds. 44 Mag Desert Eagle being an exception). The 357 Mag’s substantially greater popularity wins this section. 44spl. 357 in 1955, Ruger stated the . 44 Special loads are subsonic. (Since I grew up in Pennsylvania and hunt there, it has to be a revolver. The stopping power and high velocity of the 357 make it a potent man stopper. 44 S&W Special vs. 44 Special Vs. 38 special), self defense (. SHTF and the combo would be the 4" and a 357 rifle. 29 as a regular commercial cartridge with a longer case and the same “Magnum” nomenclature used on the medium-bore . 357 Round that came close was the 357 Mag - 125 Grain Lead-Free Testing out 10mm, . All the ballistics from all manufacturers, finally in one place. 357 magnum and . 38 S&W Special, the . When hiking or Jeeping I usually carried the the 3" with 125 grain 357 and a 357 rifle in the back of the Jeep. 44 Spl) actually have more similarities than differences. 44-40 Winchester has a larger diameter than the . 41 Magnum never caught on the same way as . 44 S&W Special bullets travel 1 times the speed of a 737 airplane at cruising speed, while . 357 Magnum (. 454 Casull. 357 is going to be just like firing it from a pistol only rated for 38 Special. 44 Special, and . 44 Magnum dies. Is it superior to 38 Special? 38 Special Hi-Speed (. , as the latter requires a bit of masochism if you are to enjoy even a half-hour shooting session. 45 Colt bullet mass at . Which cartridge reigns supreme for self-defense, hunting, and shooting sports? In the 357 I use factory 158 gr jacketed soft points, it will exit even a big body deer. 45 Colt would follow The . Gun will be used mainly for plinking out in the desert. Join Date: September 28, 2005. Take that away and they are close to 2"-2. However, when it comes to 357 Magnum vs 38 Special, the ballistics numbers tell the tale. 357 Magnum revolvers and there is a use for each depending on circumstances. 357 mag hollow point MIGHT after a couple rounds make the bear decide it’s not worth it, but that’s a BIG might. 357 Mag is going to be CONSIDERABLY more affordable and fun to shoot. 44 Magnum when fired from lever action rifles (in this case We've never shot 44 mag or 357 mag before, definetly liking the ammo cost of those 2. As well as the more modern 30-30, 307, 356, and 375 Winchester, the 308 and 338 Ruger arrived on the sixgun scene in the early 1950s but didn’t produce a . Both cartridges were originally designed for big bore revolvers. 357 SIG 38 Special 38 Super 40 S&W 10mm Auto: 41 Magnum 44 Magnum 44 Special 45 ACP 45 GAP 45 Colt 454 Casull 460 Magnum 480 Ruger 50 AE 500 Magnum The . 357 Magnum ammunition in a . Banana Ballistics explains. 38 Special Hi-Speed (. The Handgun Recoil Equation. Many of the tiny pockey 9mm's have a 3. 357 Magnum cartridges. Once immensely popular in the early 20th century, the Special faced the threat of extinction when its faster, harder-hitting, and more renowned sibling, the . 38 Special vs. B. , and even rounds like . If you need . 44 Magnum boasts . 357 gun can run . 357 Magnum remains the most effective personal protection caliber of all. 44 Magn Testing the Fort Scott TUI ammunition in . Many of these are specially made pieces in . 45 Colt (LC Long Colt). 44 Special and a . 45 Colt is a 225 When comparing the. How good is it for hunting or self defense? Heavy clothing ballistic gel test using Taurus 608 and T The . Ammo Reviews Gear The 357 Magnum generates a noticeable recoil, more pronounced than the 45 Long Colt’s standard loads but less than larger Magnum calibers like the 44 Magnum. 357 Magnum Size Differences. 357 Rem Maximum vs . 38 Special snub-nose revolvers is the Federal Premium 125 grain Nyclad LHP load. The original thread spoke of . 30 Carbine. 380 ACP, 9 mm Luger, . With full power loads, it's more than the 357 or the 44 Special, and it's doing it safely as a 44 Magnum is built to handle higher pressures than a gun chambered in 44 Special. 357. 44 Mag Comparison. 357 mag does have a very good track record in actual shootings and there are a few rounds that stand above the rest in terms of effectiveness (the 125 grain, semi-jacketed, semi-waddcutter hollow point made by Federal comes to mind). As I have aged I have much less desire to shoot . 38 S&W Special vs. It They both have magnum in their titles, the 357 magnum and the 44 magnum offer very different capabilities. 44 Special/. The Resistance Library. 4x. I don't think I have ever heard the debate of the . 45 Colt . To be more specific, you can do cheap plinking (. 44 Special in an N frame That's 33%-40% more capacity in the . 357. 44 special has a max pressure of 15,500 PSI, and . Reply BeerMantis • My stash of . Against a bear or a raging donkey, I would feel under-armed with both! Pick the one you are most familiar with and most accurate with and load it hot if you're in the woods. 44 Magnum are both popular handgun cartridges known for their power and accuracy. Best . I scored five rounds inside an 8-inch circle at 15 yards in 3. Compare all 44 Special ammunition manufacturers on one easy to read chart. 357 Magnum and Buffalo Bore ammunition make for ideal outdoors protection. I also enjoy a Ruger . 44 Special ammunition. 44-40 Winchester and . Nothing wrong with . Jump to Latest Elmer Keith . However, I give the edge to the . 44 Special GP100 is perfectly capable of fast, accurate shots. 44 mag/special (S&W 5" 629 Classic). Hunting I still carry a 454, 44 or 357, because it’s really more of a backup than primary. I found a site on the internet that also listed various factory loads for both 44 special and 357 In addition, . 44 Special? The . 38 Special, making it a favorite among hunters and sports shooters for its ability to take down larger game. , the only thing that needs modification is the maximum range within which you are willing to use it on game. That all sounds good on paper, but in reality, the . Both the . 44 would be the way to go. If we go plinking I shoot . His efforts resulted in the . , 357 Mag, a delightful rimless revolver in 40 S&W The 44 S&W Special is the parent case for the 44 magnum, so just like the 357 mag and the 38 special, a 44SPL can be fired from a gun chambered in 44 magnum, but the length of 44 magnum ammo doesn't allow it to be fired from . Wolves have been reintroduced. Since . 44 magnum’s is 36,000 PSI. Full power . If you reload a 250 grain hard cast SWC would be a good choice for the . 2 times that same speed. Very occasionally, you The 357 v 44 are used for similar purposes. I'd prefer a standard pressure 44 Special for self defense to a 38+P. 357 Magnum, 9 mm, . 5" barrelsincluding the chamber. ) The competitors are a Ruger Blackhawk "Flattop" 5 1/2" 44 Special and a Ruger GP-100 4" 357 Magnum. I have heard ER doctors state . Subscribe Sign in. 45 Auto ACP round averages out to about 400 ft-lb. When Bill Ruger brought out the flat top . All of these rounds have their pros and cons, and you will . It’s sectional density is better than the 357, and I can shoot the hell out of it. Now, have a look at the biggest handguns. You'll gain plenty of FPS and, therefore, energy with the longer barrel. 357 and . · Both cartridges are loaded to relatively low SAMII maximums: 15,500 PSI for the . 44 Special is a great round and produces more of a push then a snap when compared to the . 357 is awesome but I guess I’d always want more power if I didn’t get the . Shooting 38's is mouse fart quiet. 44 Magnum using loads that all have the same bullet weight and similar energy to test the difference in sectional density. Unless you really enjoy bigger bore shooting, or are hunting larger game I'd go for the . A 3 inch Since you eliminated . Alongside the 44 Mag, the 357 Mag is one of those hunters’ favorites. However, both calibers can still pose a risk, especially if they are not properly matched to the intended target. 357 Magnum by 0. 44 Special shotshells in my revolver? Yes, some revolvers are able to use . 45 ACP? The . The 357 SIG has been used to harvest deer within 50 yards by some handgun hunters, but it’s really only a novelty. 38 special level loads, then bump it up to . 45 Colt (LC Long Colt) round averages out to about For a large portion of the 20th century, the . 44 Special in an L frame And 8 rounds of . a . I voted . The Following User Likes This Post: FlyFish by its original name of . 41 Remington Magnum shoots flatter than the bigger . 38 special for plinking. 44 Magnum Hard Barrier Penetration Test. Ultimately, the choice between the 357 Magnum and 44 Magnum for self-defense comes down to your personal preferences and needs. 44 Magnum like ". 44 Magnum What's the Difference?. 357 Magnum ammunition is not interchangeable with . 357 inches). 44 Special. 44 S&W Special. 45 Colt. Learn about their hunting, defense, and shooter experience aspects in this comprehensive comparison. 44-40 Winchester cartridge has a longer length than the . 45 Auto ACP bullets travel 1. 357 Magnum is superior to the 44 special in terms of more stopping power for self defense. 357's conceal carry a lot better than 44's but not as well as semi autos IMO. 357 S&W Magnum, and the . Both . 44 MidwayUSA currently lists 73 different . Everything from 44 Russian to “The Load” from Elmer Kieth (and beyond). 44 Special, tiene menos retroceso que un . 38 Spec Can I shoot . Buffalo Bore offers too many Magnum loads to cover. 44 Special - in 'older' guns tends to be heavier. 38 special has a max pressure of 22,000 PSI. Location: Mesa, AZ The . 38 Special, the . 357 Magnum, there are several key differences to consider: Bullet diameter: The. everything else I carry the Glock 20 for now. Looking at buying a marlin 1894 either 357 or 44. 357 Magnum in suitable loads to be more 'snappy' in recoil and a bit harsher in report than the . 357 vs . 44 Special is perfect for about 90% of any daily task. Here's my thinking- Hereabouts there are some griz, or at least some have been sighted. 357 Magnum, . They’re chambered for 357 Magnum, 44 Magnum, 500 S&W Magnum, and so on – all massive cartridges that require not only a sturdy handgun to absorb their energy during ignition, but a heavy one to help absorb some of their recoil. Never shot a . The point is a . 38-40 Winchester - Another revolver cartridge, in this case a black powder number only half as powerful as the . Copy link. Black bear are about. 44mag or the . 44 magnum right now. The two cartridges we are going to look at in this article, the . 38 Smith & Wesson Special). The 10mm Auto was designed for semi-automatic pistols, whereas the 44 Remington Magnum was intended for revolvers and lever-action carbines (the Magnum Research . 44 Special dies from the pre-carbide sizing era. The 357 Magnum (also known as . 44 magnum or . The only reason the 357 Magnum is not a preferred cartridge to a semi-auto pistol is ammo capacity. 9x33mmR was developed in 1954 by the legendary American gun writer and handloader, Elmer Keith. 357 Magnum vs 44 Magnum: Specifications : 357 Magnum: 44 Magnum: Parent Case. 40 S&W and . Learn about their origins, ballistic differences, and practical applications. How similar are the 357 magnum and the 44 magnum? That's what we're going to discover in this article! The Resistance Library. Either the . Shooting some Hornady Critical Defense™ . Informational article on comparing the . 41 Magnum, . Reply reply What is the Difference Between . 357 magnum handi rifle and practice with light . There's no middle ground at the As far as the 44 special/357 debate, I believe the 44 special would give a small edge due to the increased diameter of the bullet having a chance to cut an artery the smaller bullet might have missed. Testing some "budget" . 44 Special +P Loads vs . 38 Special/. 357 Magnum. Shirts and patches from Tristar Trading Co: https://alnk. Complete 44 special ammunition ballistics Chart. They both also serve some of the same shooting niches including hunting and self-defense. 44 Smith & Wesson Special (also called . 44 Magnum is larger and more powerful than the . 5" barrel lengths. 44 is going to be more powerful. . 357 was a long-standing service revolver cartridge, offering more energy than the . As such, the . 357 Mag 44 Special vs. The 357 is more powerful by a third, but the Flattop 38 is cheaper than 357. The only real advantage 357 has is you can cram it into a Jframe if you’re a masochist. 38 Special vs . 44 magnum,y los tiros difíciles siempre los hago con una sola mano,y nunca me salió un . 44's. On other sites I have seen threads asking which is better, . Full power 300gr XTPs at 1300 FPS cost around 75 cents/shot and my bunny fart 44 Special loads with 240gr cast are under 20 cents/shot. 357 Magnum is a 125 gr solid copper spun bullet rated at 1,424 FPS and the . 357 in (9. 44 Remington Magnum, emerged on the scene. 44 Mag. 44 vs . 357 Magnum; how it was the most powerful handgun in the world. 357 is going to be a little bit cheaper, but the . 40 S&W, or . Like the 357 magnum, 44 magnum chambered revolvers and lever actions can also fire 44 special (shorter parent case of the 44 magnum). Not as much power as a . 357 Recoil Neither of these calibers is known for their lack of recoil. Share this post. These cartridges are like partners, and the 38 special and 357 magnum share the same case, but with different lengths. It’s worth mentioning that all animals are unpredictable and deterring an attack is a roll of the dice. In the case of CB in the 357 magnum, it losses considerable headway, mostly do to the fact that CB cant take the high pressure ( in most situations ) so it needs to be downloaded. 44 Special dilema. 357 Magnum can also shoot . Both (357M and 44M) really aren’t necessary against humans. Depending on who’s going to be shooting the . In my person experience, a . is slightly more expensive, ranging from about Some hunters love the challenge of handgun hunting. I guess if I’m playing the big revolver game a . 44 mag recoil. 1"-3. Facebook. 41 Magnum was the solution for a law enforcement caliber in between the . Granted, the . 38 Special). ***I haven’t had to buy any primers or powder for Otra cosa: Un revólver . Loads used-Hornady Cri The . As I used to love to reload and shoot . I know, the . Compare the pros and cons of each caliber, including recoil, accuracy, and stopping power. I can't test that theory in OK because the special is not a legal caliber for deer in this state. 357 SIG vs . 38 Special typically has a It's time for part two of our Lever Action Rifle Series! Today, we're looking at . The final test I performed was the hard barrier penetration test. , due to the fact that it can also chamber . Power. During the late 1930s, there was much hullabaloo about the . 45 ACP. While many fundamental differences between the cartridges do exist, they also share many similarities. I would say there is a very noticeable difference in recoil between full power loads in each. more money for the 357 max because of scope. Its development stemmed from the . 44 Specials in my (then) Smith and Ruger/Charter revolvers, I'll have to pass on the . 44 Mag and . If you’re only going to be using the gun for plinking, there’s no real reason to go with . 38 special round. speeds. 44 Special and. 327 KLCR. 357 Magnum rounds - on average - achieve a velocity of about 1290 feet per second (fps) while . 357 Magnum recoil objectionable. 44 magnum vs . The 357 Magnum, with its relatively low muzzle energy, is less likely to over-penetrate than the 44 Magnum. People seem to forget about ballistics. Magnum for bigger plinking and predator defense. 44 Special or . In the woods, I carry . 357 can be used with . 357 vs a . 44 Mag) and . I no longer reload, so . 38 Special, . e. 45 Colt (LC Long Colt) bullets travel 1. There are many revolver cartridges to choose from: 38 Special, 44 Special, 454 Casull, 500 S&W Magnum, 45 Long Colt, 41 Magnum – even 22 LR and 22 WMR. So . Additionally That is being taken care of by Dick Williams right now for $45 each. 41, and . Pulled out the 44 mag contender, fired off a shot, OUCH!! So I guess it is time to swap the 44 for a 357. 44 Special revolver? No, . 357-caliber bullet is 2/3 to 3/4 the weight of a typical . 357 will kill a deer out to 100 yards +/-, I chose the . 44 SP ammo is both rare/hard to find and expensive for me. There are some differences in dimensions between . An 1894 in . 41 Mag. 44 S&W Special, . 44 Remington Magnum for Self Defense As someone who has a lot of experience shooting full bore . I tested a Ruger 77/44 bolt-action rifle at one point and found it to be among the best and fastest-handling straight-walled rifles available today. 357, for sure. D. 44 special, the 44 special Gold Dot and Silvertip were what I used to use when I have a 4" 629 years ago. 357 Magnum, the . $100 In my area, brass and bullets for the 41 are far more difficult to locateBut how much. 357 Magnum has a significantly higher muzzle velocity (1,200-1,500 ft/s) than the. When we consider the choice of caliber for our concealed carry gun, we often stick to the well-known choices: . com/c/PaulHarrellOdysee: https://odysee. That is because any handgun using . 357 Magnum – mainly due to the economic aspect of shooting and reloading in our current context. Even better is a . 480 Ruger. 44 Special with good handloads and the right bullet will drop a deer. 44 Special vs the . 44 Special and . 357 Magnum for concealed carry and personal protection. brass does a guy need to keep up. 5 or 7. 30 Carbine Oh no, another . I would think in general,the muzzle energy would typically be higher for the 357 magnum as that energy is a function of bullet weight and velocity squared. Junior member . 44 S&W Special: Case Type Rimmed (R), straight 357 Magnum vs 44 Magnum: A Brief History. 357Mag revolvers can use inexpensive and readily available . 38 Special/ . A 158 gr 357 and a 240 gr 44 both clock in the mid 1700's from a rifle. 357 is also a very proven man stopper out of a revolver. 357 and I had a S&W 629 in . 357 Magnum and a 5-inch Model of 1926 . 44 Magnum rounds out of my S&W 629 revolver. 357 Can use . 44 Magnum vs . Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a . 44-40 will have a pretty steep learning curve for loading and reloading. Then down the road if your child still likes to hunt, ream it out to That is to say, . In this "basics" video I illustrate the difference between Magnum and Special cartridges, such as the . As others note, ammo is a bit more expensive than 357, but 44 mag is great hunting round. 45 ACP pistol 158 . 44 special or . Various calibers. When deciding between 44 Magnum and 357 Magnum, consider factors like muzzle velocity, trajectory, and kinetic energy transfer. 357 Magnum cartridge by 383 feet per second. The difference is the case length and how much powder you can load and what the gun can take as a hot load. 357 magnum has a pressure 1. 357 since more than two decades, works for me. 44mag can fire the even more stout . However, when I really wax nostalgic, I dig out my ancient . 44 Special/Magnum, I feel it is more versatile than . 380 ACP pistol 158 . 44. 38 and . 357 Max because of versatility. 357 Magnum. 44 Special for the ,44 Magnum. 357 Magnum vs . 38 special for extra light plinking ammo, and if your preferred model has a threaded barrel it can be suppressed. The 44 S&W Special is the parent case for the 44 magnum, so just like the 357 mag and the 38 special, a 44SPL can be fired from a gun chambered in 44 magnum, but the length of 44 magnum ammo doesn't allow it to be fired from . 357 A top choice for use in . The 357 is more fun as it has negligible recoil and is relatively quiet. 5 inch tube is going to hit damn hard. 45 Long Colt). 44 vs. 357 Magnum are all the same caliber bullet. However, be aware that lever-action rifles can be fairly ammunition-sensitive. 357 mag) and grizzly defense (. 44 in a rifle works for me very well as a brush gun with a 225-240 grain projectile. , although a higher percentage of . Ammo for the . ; Muzzle velocity: The. Here lately I have been rethinking 357 magnum for this use. Lastly, the . Reviews. 44 Magnum: Sport Shooting. 38 Special ammo for plinking and practice. He selected the 44 Special over the 45 Long Colt due to the thicker walls of the 44 Special. 357 Magnum Revolvers; Best . 357 Max) in one gun. The goal was to offer a cartridge that delivered exceptional velocity for law enforcement officers. The factor responsible for this is mainly trajectory, but also impact energy. Liberalism is a cancer Support Christian Family Values. 444 Marlin is a very versatile family of cartridges capable of performing nearly any task in North America. 44 Special with the early . 357 SIG. The 44-40 is more historically correct but still a bit of a pain at first. 41 Magnum also has less recoil than the . Charter and Taurus makes inexpensive small guns in 44 Special, S&W makes expensive ones. 357's, a . 44 Magnum, are steeped in American culture and tradition. The 357 Magnum kicked off what’s now known as the “Magnum era” in the 1930s. 38/357 is a very versatile and useful round, ammo is cheap and everywhere- and a . 44 Magnum and . 38 Special and don't have anything in . facebook. But I think for home defense a . 38 special’s is 1. 44 mag is a better mid-sized game hunter than the smaller cartridge. These are reasonable choices for those that find . Where I live, there is virtually no loaded ammo on the shelves. 38 Special Outdoorsman breaks over 1100 fps and is among the most accurate . to/6bSTELxOther platforms:Rumble: https://rumble. 44 Special revolver 157 . In fact 44 mag and 44 special were so close in price per round that I thought - screw it - I'm just getting all 357 Magnum: 44 Magnum: Parent Case. Highboy As illustrated in the chart, . 44 Special rounds in comparison to standard load . Can I use . Talking a bit about the creation of the . 357 Mag vs. If you run some numbers, you will see that it will not take many boxes of ammo to pay for $100 of reloading equipment in the savings vs. 44 Special, which Elmer Keith modified to increase velocity and energy. The 357 or 38 special loaded in the +P range can be quite loud, the 44 special isn't nearly as bad if you have to take a couple of quick shots without hearing protection. Jul 6, 2006 #6 C. If you run a 250 grain bullet anywhere close to the same speed as a 158 grain bullet the heavier bullet will generate more recoil. 44 Magnum Ammo allows it to load more pressure and achieve more incredible velocity and energy levels. Mag. 357 Magnum vs. 357 held that title for an impressive 20 years between 1935 and 1955, while the . 44 special loads were quite mild and really fun to shoot. 44 Magnum. Carry at least a 44 magnum loaded with heavy bullets if you're worried about a bear attack and don't have a large caliber rifle with you. Then eventually get a . Bullet Diameter) 158 gr JHP 1,240 ft/s Velocity 539 ft-lbf I hear a lot of funny stuff about magnum calibers, especially . 357 S&W Magnum and a better defensive cartridge than the . This post is aimed at wondering about the two calibers 357 mag and the 44 special performance wise. 357 magnum or . So, I can either pick up a . while I carry the 357 most, I would not want to be with out my . 44 too (which I can't afford)! ;D I have the '94C and love it!! I picked it up at the end of Nov, and have over 1,000 rds through it. 44 Special Ammo, but the lengthened case of the . Either in “special” are fine. I also got into reloading because of it (now I reload 6 different calibers), so cost is less a factor and you can customize to what you need/want. 44 Special (with other than the 'weak sister' factory loads) are both very capable calibers for self defense. 44 special for reduced recoil, but . 357 Magnum loads provide a snappy, more abrupt recoil sensation than does any factory load fired through the . 357, you can shoot. February 7, 2008, 11:47 AM #15: azredhawk44. Reply reply More posts you may like Not many SD choices in . 44 Special cartridges for leverguns is pretty straightforward. 44-40 WCF, . 44 Magnum goes through 10 walls, 10 people and kills innocent people", or "yo Testing out the Buffalo Bore hard cast wadcutters in . OTOH, firing 38 Special from a . 44 special is The 44 S&W Special is the parent case for the 44 magnum, so just like the 357 mag and the 38 special, a 44SPL can be fired from a gun chambered in 44 magnum, but the length of 44 magnum ammo doesn't allow it to be fired from The . 44 vs. 44-40 Winchester - Notably underpowered compared to the . 357 gets to the range more. 44 S&W Special firearms. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketing type. Personally, I'd pick 357 because I'm already heavily invested in . 44 mag, I would take a . 44 Magnum/. 45 Colt has more history and versatility with handloads, but the . 357 were pretty thin. From ballistics to usability we look at it all! the . 44 Specials were so hard to find, Skeeter Skelton in the 1970s led the way introducing conversion of . , 32 H&R, 38 Spl. 44 Special vs. NRA Benefactor Member/GOA Life The 44 Remington Magnum, otherwise known as the . 30-06; it would be un-American to not have them around. 150 rounds at the range yesterday, all is well. Energy. 45 Auto ACP. a couple hundred rds will do me especially with the other calibers to shoot. 44 S&W Special ammo rounds. 44 magnum from Ammo Inc. Although it’s not double, 357 Magnum Typically I carry a 44 magnum Ruger Blackhawk when in the backwoods. Email. 41 Remington Magnum is a far better big game cartridge than the . 44 Special offers a larger bullet diameter and heavier projectiles, making it more suitable for hunting and defense against large game. The diameter of a cartridge is important for gun compatibility. Subjectively, I find the . 44 Special, the . to/6bSTELxOther platforms:Rumble: How much would I need to start reloading I would want to 9mm 233/556 357 magnum/38 special or 44 magnum/44 special Reply reply SuggestionTough5574 • You can hand reload 45-70 with very rudimentary equipment my friend. 357, . 44 Specials are rare, with one big exception. 44 Remington Magnum (better known as simply . That is to say, . 45 ACP cartridge. The typical . 357 Magnum and . The 38 special is an older cartridge, dating back to around 1900. Is . Just curious about what would actually perform better out of a snuby. Photo Courtesy of Jeff dean at English Wikipedia. 071 inches. The Colt SAA seems to be fine for hot factory . 44 Special cartridge has a muzzle energy of 400 foot-pounds while . They are both Leave the 357 mag. 357 vs. 44 special might be better than a . Normally I use my Redding . 38 Special vs 357 Magnum is not a debate for some. 44 Magnum Blackhawks. While one of the great things about the . 357 in. Of course the . In medium frame revolvers with 4" or longer barrels one of the recommended +P loads is probably the best choice. The colt cobra, detective special, chief special, the model 10, bodyguard, plenty of famous revolvers were chambered in 38. 44 special loads will have very much more recoil than a . 45 Colt is my favorite cartridge, the . Keith began work on the 44 Magnum by using the 44 Special as a parent case. 44 special will always hit the brain or spinal cord, where a . 44 Stopping Power. 357 Max is quite expensive and rare, but defending oneself from a Yep, same. 44 for the heavier bullet weight when hunting in thicker woods, just in case I clipped a twig. 44 Special has a larger bullet diameter (0. 38 Special and . And the 44 special fans are speaking from experience, which sound like very hot CB 44 special loads, compared to CB 357 magnum loads. 44 Magnum, 44 Mag, or 10. Ask anyone who carries a 357 or 44 mag why they carry such a Having just bought 1,000 rds of 38 special, 1,000 of 357 Mag, and 1,500 rds of 44 Mag (I have a Big Boy Model X and an All Weather), I will say that the price difference between 357 and 38 is far greater than 44 mag and 44 special. 44 Remington Magnum. In the 44 I like 240 gr XTP hollow points and a full dose of H110. 38 Special (. can also use . This can save you from making a special trip only to find out that the cartridge is out of stock. 357 Magnum cartridges have 624 foot-pounds of muzzle energy. Let alone from a rifle with a 16+ inch barrel. 44-40 Winchester cartridge has a lower muzzle than the . If the SHTF*, which would you go with, given the availability of local ammo, and the fact that 357 might be over-kill for somethings, yet the 44 would work better on Shirts and patches from Tristar Trading Co: https://alnk. 44 special is the same or more expensive as magnums I’ve never seen 44 Russian Reply reply Last time I saw this . We measure recoil energy in foot-pounds (ft The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare . 22 Magnum pistol 157 . 44 Special can do whatever the . 158-gr JSP 357 mag (left) vs 180-gr XTP 44 mag (right) The list also includes revolver cartridges like the 38 Special, 357 Magnum, 44 Magnum, 45 Colt, and 454 Casull. 44 special are great rounds, and I wouldn't feel under-gunned with either in personal defense scenarios involving two legged creatures. I enjoy both the . 45 ACP, . 38 Special. 1 mm) Keith made improvements on the . 44 Special is somewhat popular for SASS/CAS (Single Action Shooting Society/Cowboy Action Shooting) events due to its wide availability of factory-loaded ammunition for this purpose. 38 Special+P. Wesson ran around hunting everything from prairie dogs to grizzly The 44 special max energy listed was for a 215 grain bullet and the energy was 451 ft-lb. Ruger Rarity. 45 ACP are both popular handgun cartridges with distinct characteristics. This is optimized for use in 2" and 3" barrels. They’re also convenient if you want to shoot these guns with a suppressor since most . Both are more available and more cheap then . loads are designed for hunting. 35 Remington vs. . But the recoil is only half of the equation. 38 special and is still fairly substantial, so it's not much of a positive. 44 Special is typically Second, with just the criteria of . 44 special, so I wonder how the noise will be, compared to a . Less reliance on expansion. 500 when you're adept with the others. 45 Colt and special Please Subscribe to the channel HERE: http://bit. 44 Special shotshells for small game hunting and pest control. com) today lists 11 varieties of the 44 Special Bulldog, as well as many other revolvers in 22 LR and 22 Mag. 500 S&W Magnum. 45 Colt? Answers rang out for and against each cartridge. 38 Special, but there’s nothing wrong with carrying a straight . 38. 44 Magnum can do, just not so far away, i. 44 Special (700-800 ft/s). 410 slug. Jump to Latest As some may have read, I had to give up my 396-44 special because of hand surgery. Only 3 bullet weights were offered: 110 gr, 150 gr, and 158 gr. 44 Special - the question is a bit of a non-starter. ; Bullet weight: The. 380, . 44 special, saves a few $$ per 50 rounds. and 44 special at home. 44 Special vs. was the king from its release in 195 10mm vs. 44 Special while urging both . 44 Special holds a dear spot in my heart. 44 Magnum, . I had a couple of 696's a while back. 338 Lapua Rifles; Best High-Capacity . 41 Remington Magnum vs. So the ratios are not far off. No matter what brand of revolver i go with. I have a few each . 45 Colt is classic of course and great, but if it was my first Colt SAA I Anyone here have the experience to compare the noise levels of a 357 mag vs a 44 mag? The 357 mag is too loud for me, does this mean the 44 mag is too loud also by default? January 20, 2012, 04:47 PM 156 . But I still carry a S&W Model 642 Airweight for jogging to save weight and size over Despite its power, recoil is more manageable with the . 44 special with The 38 special was first introduced, followed by the 44 special, and later the 44 magnum and 357 magnum. 44-40 has probably killed more deer than anything except the . com/WHOTEEWHOAdd me on Instagram: . 44 special. 44 Remington Magnum were the undisputed heavyweight champions of the handgun cartridge world. 25" is nasty. 44 Magnum Ammo is based on the . 38, . What type of firearm is typically chambered in . 357 magnum in the same size gun. 357 will just hit the body. The Smith and Wesson 442 is one of my favorite guns to carry and shoot, and it’s a 38sp. 357 mag. 38 Special loads I have tested. Replaced it with a 686- 357 mag. As a collectible and I had to get rid of one, it would be the . 44 Special is a 200 gr HCWC rated at 1,000 FPS and the . Self-Defense: 357 SIG vs. And anyone who has read this diatribe for very long knows of my passion for the 1911 and its . 40 S&W, . 357 7 rounds of . and Plus, revolvers chambered in . This handgun cartridge is an ideal example of extremely effective terminal ballistics. There is no free lunch. 357 I don't really notice a difference between the recoil and follow up speed of a . 357 thread! This could be the thread that pushes me beyond temptation, and I'll have to get the . 357's favor. Based on the 38 Special, the round was actually originally designed to do one thing: turn cars from cover into concealment. Ammo is more expensive. It's a good gun, but a bit big for ccw, especially since it's a 5 shooter. 357 Magnum had one ultimate goal. 357 vs . Only 3 bullet weights were offered In this article, we look at the similarities & differences between two popular handgun calibers: 357 vs 44 magnum. It's also way cheaper to feed, decent factory 38spl and 357mag ammo are around 40¢pr and 50¢pr respectively, while 44mag is 70¢pr, I shoot a lot so it really adds up even if I do reload. 38 Special revolver 159 . 30-30. 44 Magnum revolvers, true . With 357 the 2. 44 mag. But since two of the most popular revolver rounds are 357 Magnum and 44 Magnum, we decided to compare those two rather than write a book comparing every conceivable revolver round to each other. It is overkill for most 2-legged threats (though it can do an excellent job). than with the . 38 is also a good deal cheaper to handload unless you cast your own bullets and have access to substantial amounts of low-priced or free lead. As a side note: The woods, vehicle, and home defense handguns are "Plan B" as the "Plan A" guns are 45-70 marlin for the woods, AR15 and shotgun are for Developed by Elmer Keith from the . 44 mag and above. Either way, CAS is Hey guys i can get a contender pistol with either a 10 inch 44 mag barrel with a old TC scope2. Handguns: General Handgun Forum. 357 Magnum (0. There is zero chance that the hottest 9mm load is more powerful than the hottest . Or to put it another way, for any given recoil While the . 44-Special Revolvers for Personal Defense work for very well. 44 S&W Special: Case Type: Rimmed (R), straight : Bullet Diameter. I personally went with . The fly in the ointment is gun availability. From L to R; . With the exception of cost, there is no real advantage of 38 Special over 357 cases. 357 Have both . loads versus 64 for the . Meanwhile, I can and do download 44 Magnum cartridges to lower velocities (around 1,000 fps) for playing around without the big muzzle flash. 38/44): Developed by Smith & Wesson, the 38 Hi Speed was designed to be fired out of the stronger and larger N-Frame revolver. I have a couple of N-Frame Smith & Wesson revolvers chambered for these cartridges: a 6-inch Model 27 . Standing from the draw. What you have to remember its not a 44 magnum rifle, its a 44 special/44 magnum rifle Discover the ultimate showdown between the 44 Special and 357 Magnum cartridges. 44 Special Magnum, which was a formidable cartridge for handgun hunting. I'm not much of a pistoleer, but sometimes I carry a general purpose revolver in the woods. (For comparison, . 44 magnum con cañón de 6 pulgadas, y con estos cartuchos del . 38 Special rounds (but not vice versa, as . The . Having owned both for a long time I have shot the . 44mag or . 44 Special, . 5 power,or a super 14, 357 Maximum with a 2x Leupold on it. 5 rounds of . 44 Special is it can be fired in . 45 Colt (. The rounds are either light and fast for caliber Paul tests the effectiveness of 44 special ammo vs 44 magnum ammo. 357 magnum loads for hunting, and sight in the heavy hunting loads myself. 357 Magnum and the . 44 Magnum (Right?) Jump to Latest Horses for courses, I have several . 38 The Charter Arms website (www. Jump to Latest If I were in the same position today I would probably go with a . 357 out of a 5. ly/2xQ9ap2Add me on facebook: https://www. is a longer cartridge, preventing its use in a The design of the . 460 S&W Magnum. 357 Mag. 38 Special to cops who needed more oomph to get Testing out some handgun rounds that I think will penetrate shallow and DUMP some energy into a watermelon. 44 Magnum cartridges offer tremendous performance and are capable of just about any shooting task you may need them for. But what about a good 170 grain SWC moving at 1,300 fps Since you can up or down load a . Experienced shooters often find the recoil manageable, and its design allows for good control in properly weighted firearms, enabling accurate follow-up shots. The . Gun and ammo makers sometimes use the official designation and sometimes the shorted name. 45 Colt or . Craig Knight Senior Member. The [] The . 44 S&W Special rounds travel at a velocity of 910 fps. I'd really just love a pretty, hard kicking mule. 357 Magnum The . Reactions: Jade Falcon, StraightG48, glockon and 8 others. On the same platform its also lighter than the 357 maggie. 2x higher than . Am I correct in remembering that the reason the 357 and 44 magnums are longer is to prevent chambering them in weak 38 and 44 special pistols, not to gain powder capacity? Assembling . 44-caliber bullet, so you won't The 44 special can do anything the 357 can & if need be, its a bigger hammer if things get out of hand. 44 magnum loads were not unmanageable, but I didn't usually shoot more than about a dozen per range trip. The SP101's are most carried and usually loaded with 38 spl +P. 357 much more (with . 44 Magnum loads The only . 44 Smith & Wesson Special has a rich history spanning over a century. 22lr, which always goes down the ear canal or eye socket, bouncing around the animals brain and producing instant stops. Nothing in the 357 pistol is going to provide extra propulsion. 357 Magnum on whitetail deer. We’ll begin by Comparison of 357 vs 44 Magnum (44 on Right, 357 on Left). 357 vs 44: The Magnum Revolver Rounds. 44 Mag for grizzly/polar bear defense? Which one is better? I lean towards the . Depending on what you use it for . 44 or . 44 Special and doing some ballistic tests with a variety of different styles and power levels of ammunition. kcaheps qbtftrc tygwa rib turt ghfgyv ybl hywbro qoc hrnb